SMILE or LASIK: Which Eye Surgery Is Right for You?

hello world!

In the world of vision correction, two prominent procedures have revolutionized how people achieve clear and crisp vision: SMILE and LASIK surgery. These procedures have gained widespread popularity for their ability to successfully correct refractive errors, potentially reducing or eliminating the need for glasses or contact lenses.

However, when choosing between SMILE surgery and LASIK surgery, it's crucial to understand the key differences that can help you determine the right procedure for your needs.

To help guide you toward making an informed decision about your vision correction journey, Monsoon Vision in Logan, UT, explores SMILE and LASIK eye surgery, comparing their benefits, limitations, and factors for candidacy.


Understanding SMILE Surgery

SMILE, an acronym for Small Incision Lenticule Extraction, represents the latest innovation in refractive surgery. SMILE corrects myopia (nearsightedness).

During the SMILE procedure, your eye surgeon uses a femtosecond laser to create a disc-shaped tissue layer, known as a lenticule, beneath your corneal surface. Next, a small opening is made in your cornea, through which the surgeon removes the lenticule, ultimately reshaping your cornea.

SMILE offers several advantages, including a smaller incision size, which may lead to quicker recovery, reduced risk of dry eyes, and greater corneal stability due to the preservation of corneal layers. However, SMILE is not as widely known or time-tested as LASIK.

Understanding LASIK Surgery

LASIK, short for Laser-Assisted in Situ Keratomileusis, is a widely recognized and time-tested procedure for vision correction. LASIK corrects myopia, hyperopia (farsightedness), and astigmatism.

During LASIK surgery, your eye surgeon uses a microkeratome or laser to create a small flap in your cornea. They then fold back the flap to access the underlying tissue. Using an excimer laser, the surgeon removes and reshapes the corneal tissue. The flap is repositioned, and a protective bandage contact lens may be applied to aid in the healing process.

LASIK has garnered popularity due to its high success rates, rapid visual recovery, and broad suitability for a wide range of prescriptions.

Comparing SMILE and LASIK

When choosing between Smile and LASIK, several factors warrant consideration.

Surgical Techniques

SMILE and LASIK differ in their surgical approaches. SMILE involves creating a small incision, while LASIK involves creating a corneal flap. However, both are minimally invasive.

Visual Outcomes and Effectiveness

Both SMILE and LASIK have demonstrated exceptional visual outcomes. Studies indicate high patient satisfaction rates and significant improvement in visual acuity for both procedures.


While both procedures are generally safe, being aware of potential risks and complications is crucial. Dry eyes, glare, halos, and corneal ectasia (a rare but serious condition involving corneal thinning) can occur with both SMILE and LASIK. Consulting with an experienced surgeon will help evaluate your candidacy and determine the safest and most suitable option.

Candidacy Criteria

Factors such as prescription range, corneal thickness, and age may influence the suitability of SMILE eye surgery or LASIK eye surgery for your specific case. An eye care professional will conduct a comprehensive examination and assess your eligibility for each procedure, providing personalized recommendations based on your unique needs.


The ultimate goal of both procedures is to enhance vision and decrease dependence on glasses or contact lenses. LASIK's ability to cater to a wide range of patients and fast visual recovery may make it an excellent option for people with physically demanding jobs or active lifestyles. In contrast, SMILE's minimally invasive technique and potential advantages, such as a lower risk of dry eyes, may appeal more to individuals worried about specific side effects.

Personal Preferences

Consider your preferences regarding surgical technique, recovery time, potential side effects, and long-term stability. Discussing these preferences with your eye care professional will help align the procedure choice with your expectations.

Consultation With an Eye Care Professional

You must schedule a consultation with an experienced surgeon to determine the most suitable procedure. If you’re in Logan, UT, the team at Monson Vision will evaluate your ocular health, conduct a comprehensive exam, and provide recommendations based on your eye anatomy, prescription, and lifestyle. Whether you are considering LASIK surgery or Zeiss SMILE surgery, our surgeons will help you make an informed decision.

Choosing between SMILE and LASIK can seem daunting, but understanding the subtle differences between each procedure and considering personal factors can simplify decision-making. Remember, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Consultation with an experienced eye care professional is crucial for evaluating and receiving personalized recommendations.

Whether you opt for SMILE or LASIK eye surgery, both procedures can provide life-changing vision correction, allowing you to experience the world with clarity!

If you’re in the Cache Valley area, contact Monson Vision in Logan, UT, today for SMILE and LASIK eye surgery evaluations. Take the first step towards life-changing vision correction.

menuchevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram